Only 11% of people notified of a data breach stopped doing business with the hacked company, according to RAND’s 2016 report based on a nationally representative survey of 2,038 US adults. Yet 78% of consumers told Ping Identity in 2018 they would stop engaging online with a brand that had been breached. The gap between those two numbers is the real story of customer churn after a breach, and it shapes how much a breach actually costs a business.
Both figures are true, and they measure different things: one counts what people did, the other counts what people say they would do. This page lines up the behavioral numbers, the stated-intent numbers, the cost of lost business from IBM and the Ponemon Institute, and the newest 2025 and 2026 consumer trust data, with the age and method of every survey stated so you can judge each one yourself.
What percentage of customers actually leave after a data breach?
The best behavioral number is 11%. RAND’s American Life Panel surveyed 2,038 nationally representative US adults between May 15 and June 1, 2015, and found that 11% of those who had ever been notified of a breach stopped doing business with the hacked company. About a quarter of American adults had been notified in the prior year, and 62% of those notified accepted the free credit monitoring on offer. RAND published the findings on April 14, 2016, so this is the oldest figure in this post, and it measured breaches that were mostly retail and financial incidents from the mid-2010s.
Other surveys land higher on what people did, though none is a clean behavioral record. Ponemon’s 2017 study for Centrify, which surveyed 549 consumers, found that 31% of those affected by a breach discontinued their relationship with the organization. Thales’s 2022 Consumer Digital Trust Index found that one in three consumers worldwide had been a victim of a breach, and 21% said they had stopped using a company that suffered one. Of those who left, 42% asked the company to delete their information.
Figure 1: Reported exit rates vary from 11% to 78% depending on whether the survey asked what people did or what they would do. Sources: RAND (2016), Ponemon Institute for Centrify (2017), Thales (2022), Ping Identity (2018).
Read the bars as a range, not a single answer. The 11%, 21% and 31% figures describe people who say they left after being affected. The 78% figure from Ping Identity describes a hypothetical, which is why it sits so far above the rest. A business planning for breach fallout should expect somewhere between roughly one in ten and one in three affected customers to leave, and the exact share depends on the sector, the severity and how the company responds.
Why do stated intentions and real behavior differ so much?
Ping Identity’s 2018 survey of more than 3,000 people across the US, UK, France and Germany found that 78% would stop engaging with a brand online after a breach, and 36% would stop engaging on any medium at all. The same survey found that 49% would not sign up for an online service or application that had recently been in the news for a breach. RAND’s 11% describes the same consumer population acting under real conditions, with switching costs, habit and a lack of alternatives all in play.
Three reasons explain most of the gap. Switching a bank, a mobile carrier or a health provider takes time, and many people judge the effort too high. People often learn of a breach second-hand and never connect it to a decision. And survey questions about hypothetical loyalty invite the answer that makes the respondent look careful. RAND also found that 77% of those notified were highly satisfied with how the company handled its response, which suggests a well-run notification keeps most customers in place.
Figure 2: Most notified adults rated their company’s response highly. Source: RAND, 2016 (2,038 US adults, fielded 2015).
None of that makes the 78% worthless. Stated intent is a sentiment measure, and sentiment matters when a customer is choosing between two otherwise equal providers. The related question of how often privacy concerns push people to switch brands is covered in more depth in our data on brand switching over privacy, and our consumer privacy survey roundup for 2026 shows how that sentiment has moved this year.
How much does lost business cost after a breach?
Lost business cost the average breached organization $1.38 million in 2025, according to IBM and the Ponemon Institute’s Cost of a Data Breach Report 2025. That figure fell 6% from $1.47 million in 2024, after an 11% jump the year before, and it covers revenue lost to system downtime, lost customers and reputation damage. It is about 31% of the $4.44 million global average cost of a breach, a share we calculated from IBM’s two published figures. The 2025 report covered 600 breached organizations studied between March 2024 and February 2025.
The newer 2026 edition shows the trend turning back up. IBM and the Ponemon Institute put the 2026 global average cost of a breach at a record $4.99 million, a 12% increase, based on 602 breached organizations studied between March 2025 and February 2026. IBM names higher detection, escalation and lost business costs as the drivers of that increase, though the public summaries we could verify do not break out a separate 2026 lost-business dollar figure. For the full cost picture by category, see our breakdown of the cost of a data breach in 2026.
Lost business is the line item that churn feeds. It is also the hardest to measure, because a customer who drifts away over 18 months rarely gets recorded as a breach cost, so IBM’s number is better read as a floor than a ceiling.
What happens to a company’s share price after a breach?
Share value fell 5% on average on the day a breach was disclosed, according to Ponemon’s 2017 study for Centrify of 113 companies that suffered a material breach across 16 industry sectors. Companies with poor security posture dropped by up to 7% on disclosure day, while companies with high security posture dropped by no more than 3%. The study was commissioned by Centrify, a security vendor, so treat it as industry-funded research.
Figure 3: Security posture changed how far share value fell on the day a breach was disclosed. Source: Ponemon Institute for Centrify, 2017 (113 companies).
The recovery gap is the more telling number. Ponemon found that 120 days after disclosure, poor-posture companies had not recovered their pre-breach share price, while high-posture companies were trading 3% above it. The consumer side of that study found that 65% of affected consumers said they lost trust in the organization, and it put customer churn at up to 7% for poor-posture companies. Trust loss and churn were both larger where security was weak.
How do 2025 and 2026 consumers talk about leaving?
The newest trust surveys ask about data misuse and privacy concerns rather than breaches alone, but they show the same pattern of strong stated intent and smaller actual exits. Thales’s 2025 Digital Trust Index surveyed more than 14,000 consumers in 14 countries and found that 19% had been told their personal data was compromised in the past year, and 82% said they had abandoned a brand over how it used their data. Thales did not publish a fieldwork date, and its release is dated March 18, 2025.
Usercentrics’ State of Digital Trust 2026, run by Sapio Research with 11,000 consumers in seven markets in March 2026, found that 78% of US consumers would stop using a service if their data were misused. In the same survey, only 21% of US consumers said they had stopped using a retail brand over data privacy concerns. That is the same shape as the older breach data, a large stated share and a much smaller actual one, and it holds in a different decade with a different question.
Figure 4: Stated willingness to leave is far higher than reported exits in the newest surveys. Sources: Thales Digital Trust Index 2025, Usercentrics State of Digital Trust 2026.
Because each of these surveys asks a slightly different question, do not subtract one from another. Use them together as a range: on the best evidence, one in ten to one in three affected customers leave, and three in four say they might.
How do the numbers compare side by side?
The table below lines up each source by what it measured and when, so you can see which numbers describe behavior and which describe intent.
| Source and year | What it measured | Result |
|---|---|---|
| RAND, 2016 (fielded 2015) | Notified adults who stopped dealing with the hacked company | 11% of 2,038 adults |
| Thales, 2022 | Consumers who stopped using a company that suffered a breach | 21% |
| Ponemon for Centrify, 2017 | Breach-affected consumers who discontinued the relationship | 31% of 549 consumers |
| Ping Identity, 2018 | Consumers who would stop engaging online with a breached brand | 78% of 3,000-plus consumers |
| IBM and Ponemon, 2025 | Average lost business cost per breach | $1.38 million |
| Usercentrics, 2026 | US consumers who stopped using a retail brand over privacy | 21% |
Sources: RAND (2016), Thales (2022 and 2025), Ponemon Institute for Centrify (2017), Ping Identity (2018), IBM and the Ponemon Institute (2025), Usercentrics (2026). Survey methods and populations differ, so rows are not directly comparable.
The Bottom Line
Eleven percent of breach victims leaving sounds small until you set it beside the other numbers. A third of affected consumers told Ponemon they walked away, lost business cost the average breached organization $1.38 million in 2025, and share value dropped 5% on disclosure day. A business that has been breached should plan for churn of one in ten to one in three affected customers, not the 78% that headlines quote, and should plan for the trust loss that comes with it. Fast, plain notification matters here: 77% of people RAND surveyed rated their company’s response highly. A current, plain-language policy that tells customers what data you hold and what happens if something goes wrong is part of that response, and a privacy policy generator is the quickest way to keep yours accurate. Vendors are a growing source of these incidents, so our look at third-party breach risk shows where to look first.
Frequently Asked Questions
What percentage of customers leave after a data breach? 11% of people ever notified of a breach said they stopped doing business with the hacked company, according to RAND’s 2016 report built on a nationally representative survey of 2,038 US adults fielded in 2015. Surveys that ask about intent instead of behavior report far higher figures, such as 78% in a 2018 Ping Identity poll.
How much does lost business cost after a data breach? $1.38 million on average per breach in 2025, down 6% from $1.47 million in 2024, according to IBM and the Ponemon Institute’s Cost of a Data Breach Report 2025. That is roughly 31% of the $4.44 million global average cost, and IBM names higher lost business costs as one driver of the record $4.99 million average in its 2026 edition.
Why do survey answers about leaving a breached company differ so much? Surveys that ask what people would do after a breach report 78% in Ping Identity’s 2018 poll of more than 3,000 people, while surveys that ask what people did report 31% in Ponemon’s 2017 study of 549 consumers, 21% in Thales’s 2022 index and 11% in RAND’s 2016 report. Intent is cheap, switching providers takes effort, and the questions are worded differently.
Do breaches hurt a company’s share price? Yes, briefly. Across 113 companies with a material breach, Ponemon’s 2017 study for Centrify found the share value index fell 5% on the day of disclosure on average, up to 7% for companies with poor security posture and no more than 3% for companies with high security posture.
Where the Numbers Come From
- RAND Corporation. (2016). “One-Fourth of American Adults Notified of Data Breach in Past Year; Few Consumers Penalize Hacked Companies.” Nationally representative survey of 2,038 US adults from the American Life Panel, fielded May 15 to June 1, 2015; 11% of those ever notified stopped doing business with the hacked company, 62% accepted free credit monitoring, 77% were highly satisfied with the response.
- Bitdefender Business Insights, reporting Ping Identity’s survey. (2018). More than 3,000 consumers in the US, UK, France and Germany; 78% would stop engaging online with a breached brand, 36% on any medium, 49% would not sign up for a recently breached service. Fieldwork date not stated.
- Ponemon Institute for Centrify. (2017). Press release on a study of 113 breached companies and 549 consumers; 5% average share value drop, up to 7% for poor posture, 31% of affected consumers discontinued the relationship, 65% lost trust. Commissioned by a security vendor.
- TechRadar, reporting the 2022 Thales Consumer Digital Trust Index. (2022). One in three consumers a breach victim, 21% stopped using a company that suffered a breach, 42% of those requested deletion. Sample size not stated in the article.
- Freevacy, reporting Thales’s 2025 Digital Trust Index. (2025). More than 14,000 consumers in 14 countries; 82% abandoned a brand over data usage concerns, 19% had personal data compromised in the past year. Release dated March 18, 2025.
- Usercentrics. (2026). “State of Digital Trust 2026,” conducted by Sapio Research with 11,000 consumers in seven markets in March 2026, margin of error 0.9%; 78% of US consumers would stop using a service if data were misused, 21% of US consumers stopped using a retail brand over privacy.
- IBM and the Ponemon Institute. (2025). “Cost of a Data Breach Report 2025.” Lost business cost $1.38 million, down 6% from $1.47 million in 2024; $4.44 million global average; 600 breached organizations.
- Help Net Security, reporting IBM’s Cost of a Data Breach 2026. (2026). Record $4.99 million global average, up 12%, drivers include lost business costs, more than 600 organizations studied March 2025 to February 2026.
Note: All figures verified as of November 2026. The RAND, Ping Identity and Ponemon-Centrify surveys are several years old and are the most recent public figures we could trace for those specific questions; check for newer editions before citing them after this post’s next refresh.




